Dorothy Forstein Show Notes | Her Strange Hour

In this episode of Her Strange Hour, we’re talking about the eerie and still-unsolved disappearance of Dorothy Forstein.

Dorothy Forstein was a 40-year-old wife and mother living in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. On October 18, 1949, she vanished from her home under deeply disturbing circumstances. According to reports, her young daughter said she saw an unknown man carrying Dorothy’s unconscious body out of the house. Dorothy was never seen again.

What makes this case even stranger is that Dorothy had reportedly survived a brutal attack years before her disappearance, and no clear motive has ever been confirmed. There were no easy answers, no clean ending, and no resolution for her family.

In this episode, I walk through Dorothy’s life, the earlier attack, the night she disappeared, and the questions that still surround the case decades later.

Listen to the episode here:
https://open.spotify.com/episode/39AuNL7GzYtVldkyxOPzIK?si=ESZfkMaBT_uTdTP0TwT9jA

In this episode:

• Who Dorothy Forstein was
• The frightening attack she survived before vanishing
• What reportedly happened on the night of October 18, 1949
• Why her daughter’s account made the case so unsettling
• The unanswered questions that still remain

Sources and further reading:

• The Doe Network: Dorothy Forstein case file
• NamUs: Dorothy Forstein missing person case
• The Trail Went Cold: Episode 288 — Dorothy Forstein
• American Hauntings: “The Vanished Housewife”

Related from Ivy Monroe:

Who Put Bella in The Wych Elm

Thanks for listening to Her Strange Hour, where we talk about strange stories, mysteries, forgotten cases, eerie history, mostly centered around women.